Systemic Low Expectations as a Primary Barrier to Recovery – William Kinkle Interview

William C. Kinkle, NRP, CRS (Bill) has been involved with emergency care for over 35 years. He has worked as a critical care transport provider, 911 responder, Flight Paramedic, ER and trauma SICU nurse at the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania. Bill also spent 6 years in ministry as a pastor and urban missionary. He entered the healthcare workforce at age 17 as a nursing assistant and became a paramedic at age 19. As an emergency medicine expert he published multiple academic papers primarily focused on airway management and lectured on these topics around the world.

He was first exposed to opioids in 2004 after being prescribed oxycodone for a kidney stone, but as an emergency responder he had other risk factors. His story of addiction as a medical professional is not as uncommon. Exposure to trauma is prevalent. Yet the culture of the medical workforce makes it difficult for people in these professional positions to acknowledge a problem and seek help. A large national survey PROA did with Elevyst and RIWI in 2023 released our associated report, Opportunities for Change: An analysis of drug use and recovery stigma in the U.S. healthcare system. We found that stigma within healthcare creates barriers to seeking help, including fear of judgment, discrimination, and concerns about professional competence and trustworthiness. Notably, 38% of healthcare workers believed people with problematic drug or alcohol use had a low or no chance of maintaining recovery. The report identified healthcare facilities among the places people were least willing to seek help. Internalized stigma discourages healthcare professionals with substance use concerns from disclosing their needs or accessing treatment for fear of professional and social consequences.

I have known Bill for a number of years but first had an opportunity to sit down with him over coffee last Spring. He recently read my essay Pathways of Long-Term Recovery and the Rhetoric of “Zombie Drugs” and noted that academia drives medicine and saw the link between the absence of peer reviewed journals about xylazine recovery as a facet driving apathy in the medical professions regarding this population. Bill has a tremendous amount of knowledge as a result of his medical background and his recovery trajectory that we should pay attention to. He is now a person in long term recovery. Bill has been able to get into sustained recovery from the new drug combinations we are seeing in our communities across America. In retrospect he sees that his addiction was rooted, birthed, and fostered from unrecognized post-traumatic stress. William has received many awards for his contributions to emergency medicine and is a nationally recognized advocate for health professionals in recovery from substance use disorders.

Question One: Bill, you have contributed significantly to the communities you have served over the course of your career. I have no frame of reference for what you must have encountered in your work as a medical professional. You have saved countless lives and have also paid a price for those efforts. Working as a critical care professional has to be one of the hardest jobs there is. I understand from our conversations the role that traumatic exposure had in you developing a substance use condition. Are we doing enough to support medical professionals at risk for SUD?

Answer: The short answer is no we are not doing anywhere near enough. With respect to SUDs for medical professionals, if we did, we would not wait until people are experiencing severe challenges before we did anything at all to help them. We do not do anything preventative. Everything is reactionary and most often than not punitive. To put this in perspective I think about my own professional career. I started riding on emergency calls at age 17 and became a paramedic at age 19. I have spent my whole life immersed in what most would view as a highly traumatic environment. Normal people experience a heightened stress response when they get anywhere near the kinds of things I would start my day out with before lunch, but for me, this is where I lived. The very first thing every first responder is taught is how to properly assess a scene for safety. However, we have never really looked at how that affects our autonomic nervous systems. Our fight or flight response is the thing that keeps humans safe, we need it for survival. First responders’ fight or flight tends to be perpetually on. Soldiers are similarly trained to be hypervigilant. Threat perception becomes automatic, calmness and focus during chaos is what keeps us alive and allows us to provide lifesaving medical care under pressure. What I wasn’t taught was how to turn that off or at least regulate it when it’s not necessary. Alcohol use is prevalent in the EMS community and I learned very quickly that substances were an effective way to regulate my nervous system. This means that addiction is an occupational hazard for people like me; people who have that “thing,” you know? That thing where once you start using you start to not be able to stop. Many people involved in emergency services routinely use substances use as a coping mechanism, but for a small percentage of us (those with risk of developing a substance use disorder) this culture can be deadly. Many people think PTSD is rooted in the things we see. A common question folks ask is, “what’s the worst thing you’ve ever seen?” But we are trained to compartmentalize that stuff. We don’t see a horrific tragedy in front of us at the moment, we see problems that need solving. This framing allows us to ignore the graphic nature of horrific tragedies like school shootings or car crashes. The manifestation of PTSD I am talking about is deeper, less obvious. It is rooted in years of living hyper aware and drugs do an excellent job of managing that….until they don’t.  Military folks deploy and serve their tours for a designated amount of time and then come home. First responders “deploy” every day for their 12, 24, 36 hours shifts and then try to turn it off for a day or so before they “deploy” again. This makes it very difficult to regulate our ANS, particularly because it isn’t something we have historically looked at in the profession. The circumstances are different, but the effect on our nervous systems is identical. Meta-analysis data shows that about 1 in 5 healthcare professionals (20%) had hazardous alcohol use, another paper found 6–8% of physicians have been estimated to experience an SUD, while 10–15% of healthcare professionals misuse drugs at some point in their careers. I think these may also be underreported so it’s safe to say these numbers are much higher and I can tell you as someone on the inside, substance use is a routine part of the job for many emergency workers. For example, I worked with a physician who used to have 8 balls of cocaine delivered right to the emergency department. Another recent journal article noted that workplace stress, access to controlled medications, and stigma surrounding disclosure and treatment can increase risks and prevent timely help-seeking; fear of consequences for licensing and credentialing can further discourage professionals from seeking care.

Trauma is a huge driver of substance use across the workforce. While my first experience with addiction treatment was in 2008, it took me 16 years for me to see how my own PTSD and its relationship with my substance use. I had been under the care of some of the most renowned addiction experts in the world and they were so focused on symptom management (drug use) they completely missed the connection to how I am internally wired as a paramedic. I recall sitting in a group within a residential treatment center and the counselor asking us where our safe and happy place was. Other people talked about walking in the woods or some other serene space and when it came around to me I spoke about sitting in the trauma bay and a major call coming through. The place where I feel normal and calm is the in the midst of someone else dying. You hear very similar lines of thinking from combat veterans who come home and have difficulty adjusting to civilian life. They often lament being home, wishing they were back in Iraq or Afghanistan because life was easier there. To most folks this sounds completely counterintuitive, but for folks with PTSD we get it because in those situations life makes sense to us. We know what to do and if we’ve been trained adequately everything is automatic, that means comfortable and manageable. For me personally, opioids synthetically turned down my fight or flight response. This is also not uncommon in the medical community. Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) are common across the workforce which they are frequently reported and occur at rates comparable to or sometimes higher than the general public.

We know that medical professionals are at higher risk for SUDs but we do not do nearly enough for them. When I got into this field the CISD (Critical Incident Stress Debriefing) team would only deploy for things life plane crashes. We prepared for major incidents, never giving thought to the cumulative effects of trauma. Acknowledging a need for therapy is not in that culture. It has only been in recent years that we started to think about addressing the tragedies we see on a daily basis and have begun studying why certain folks are bothered by it, while others are not. A European study found that medical students across eight UK medical schools found that competitive training, stigma, and expectations to push through distress led students to hide their symptoms and try to cope alone. Fear of career consequences and fitness-to-practice procedures contributed to delayed help-seeking, sometimes until symptoms became more severe. This is what sets the culture to avoid seeking help.

Changing the culture is important. That would start with training on substance use as an occupational hazard and the importance of prevention to be established as the culture by the leaders out in the field. Not everyone needs therapy after a rough call, but what about working new norms into training and practice that acknowledge the risks and established self-care practice as a professional standard is as important as scene safety? There is good evidence that we tend to be like the 3-5 people we spend the most time with. Therefore, we should be vigilant and choose wisely who we spend our time with. By having a tight network of friends with characteristics we would like to emulate we naturally design a robust support network. By surrounding ourselves with others who are wired similarly we can start to disclose out deepest thoughts and struggles. There is tremendous value in having friends who understand us. More importantly, we need mentors; people who have already walked the road we are on and can guide us. Likewise, we must then also do it for others and carry on the tradition of mentorship so we can all learn to struggle well with the inevitable struggles life will bring.  Without these things we are failing to support our own. We cannot reasonably expect medical professionals to serve out careers that do not end in tragedy unless we change our culture. We do not have established wellness practices; we suit up and hit the ground standing in the path of danger to protect others even as we erode our own wellbeing.

While my experience of being a highly accomplished medical professional who subsequently used heroin, fentanyl, and xylazine and ended up homeless on the streets of Kensington is not what happens to most medical professionals, we have to look at how it happened to me. As a profession we are more at risk to develop additions than the general public and our silence and inaction is killing us. Once we are identified as having a problem, we then get help but the whole process is hit or miss. What does treatment look like? Is it a traditional short term 12 step-oriented service or a Suboxone script in a doctor’s office? It all depends on what door you walk through. We lack long-term recovery trajectories in any of these systems. Is causation considered genetic, a result of trauma or a matter of social determinants of health or combinations of these things? Our prevailing model is the brain disease model in which opioid addiction is managed in ways that you need to take medication for life. This is a limiting orientation. This is not a recovery model in which people are seen as having the capacity to heal and experience post traumatic growth and resiliency, it is a model of low expectations in our capacity to heal and to become better versions of ourselves. The brain disease model has value in offering explanations. However, for people like me being told I have a lifelong, incurable, chronic relapsing, brain disease means only one thing: unfit for duty; and that is a death sentence.

Question Two: As we do this interview, what is the thing that you want readers to take away from your experience?

Answer: The one thing I would want everyone struggling with trauma or addiction to take away from this interview is this, never give up. Under no circumstances can you give up. Perhaps it’s because I was born and raised in Philly, three blocks from where Rocky lived and I grew up with that underdog mindset, I’m not sure where it came from, but I do not give up, ever and I want anyone reading this to walk away with the same unstoppable attitude. Never give up, keep fighting, regardless of the odds. It was my experience over the years that I encountered a lot of people and a lot of different kinds of programs that have perspectives on what I should do or not do and it took years to navigate my way to what I found worked for me. We are also seeing significant shifts in drug combinations that impact the recovery processes that few of the “experts” really understand. If you haven’t recovered from xylazine and/or medetomidine please have humility and understand that your struggle and recovery was different. I recovered from heroin and fentanyl in the past, tranq is a completely unique monster. If you’ve been sober for 5, 10, 20 years you have no idea what tranq is like.

When I relapsed in 2020 there was no part of me that thought it would take 3 years to get into recovery and throughout the process I would suffer through a spinal cord injury where for a few days I wasn’t sure if I would ever walk again. Then be faced with amputation of both of my legs as well as several rounds of sepsis, months of hospitalizations, and a long list of other obstacles. I would relapse and go for help and the withdrawal was not like heroin withdrawal at all. You see, in 2020 we were still treating opioid addiction like we did heroin. I went through 32 failed buprenorphine inductions. Every 2 weeks I was in a doctors office somewhere seeking help. I locked myself in a hotel room five different times to detox unsuccessfully. At one point I locked myself in a cabin in the woods 2 hours from home for a week trying to detox myself and would go into horrible precipitated withdrawal because we hadn’t yet understood and implemented microdosing. This had a profound effect on me. If you haven’t experienced precipitated withdrawal from fentanyl, it is a particular type of hell I wouldn’t wish on anyone. My road to recovery was incredibly difficult and that is a huge understatement.

2020 to 2023 were incredibly lonely. I had spent decades helping people and I kind of thought more people would be there for me when I was in that space during those years. Yet, the phones were silent. A few people initially reached out, but when things really got hard all the folks who I thought would be there had disappeared. I lived in a small bathroom for years, and I was waiting for someone to come and help me, but nobody came. When people would reach out, or I would go for help, it often felt like I was on an assembly line of minimal support that sustained me in my use. The one time that I was hospitalized and felt comfortable because withdrawal was managed effectively, I distinctly remember my wife calling to tell me the physicians told her they were just keeping the full agonist medication dosing high in order to maintain my tolerance so when I returned to use after discharge I wouldn’t die. I had no intentions of using after discharge. I wanted recovery. But they were so focused on my autonomy and overdose prevention they forgot to tell me that their plan was to discharge me without any prescriptions. I was on 180mg of OxyContin multiple times a day and their plan was to just discharge me without any prescriptions. Their “humane” treatment was to maintain my addiction. People did not see me as worth helping. I was not in a place psychologically where I was able to seek help on my own volition, yet that is what we say we think people should do under the narrative that this is respecting their autonomy. For years I advocated against involuntary treatment. The data shows it doesn’t work. However, those data were all from a time before xylazine and medetomidine. This fact matters. I should’ve had my liberty temporarily suspended for a period of time. These drugs are too dangerous and if by chance someone survives, they are likely to have lifetime medical complications from their use. I was also incapable of making good decisions for myself on those drugs. When I had used heroin years ago I wasn’t a model citizen, don’t get me wrong, but I could function. I knew who I was and where I was. With tranq I was a complete mess. Auditory, visual, and tactile hallucinations occurred 24 hours a day. It was terrifying. I ended up in the ER a dozen times with complications from hallucinations requiring sutures. Most times instead of recognizing I was in crisis the ER staff used my visit as a form of entertainment and laughed. It was deplorable. I was unsafe and if you look at what has happened to Kensington Avenue, I don’t think anyone can argue against involuntary treatment. I am not saying jail, I am saying for a short period of time people need to be removed from the environment to actually receive help. While I fully believe in compassionate care, love, and empathy, I am someone who suffered at the hands of a lot of well-intentioned people who almost loved me to death. I cannot put my head down at night if I do not push back and say we’ve gone too far. People out there struggling with tranq deserve better than leaving them out there with the hope that they’ll one day want recovery. The most loving thing we can do is the hardest thing, involuntary treatment. I know this is a very unpopular concept, but I barely survived it and I am someone who also survived three years of homelessness back in the 2000s when heroin was the prevalent opioid. Things are dramatically different today. There is no comparison and we have to stop pretending what we are doing is compassionate. We have an obligation to protect those who cannot protect themselves. The folks who are suffering with tranq addiction are incapable of protecting themselves due to the contaminants in the drug supply. The most humane thing we can do for them is to take away their freedom for a brief period of time to allow them to recover, heal, and give them back their ability to practice volition without impairment.

I think part of me was hoping someone would come rescue me and make me get off the drugs and stay off the drugs but that did not happen. I suspect that thousands of people out there feel that way, hoping that someone would just take them off the streets and actually help them. Autonomy is the capacity for self-governance, independence, and the freedom to make informed, uncoerced decisions. These drugs are so powerful they robbed me of that. I was not capable of autonomy in the way people who have full cognition think about it. I am very fortunate to have survived those years, but looking back I wish someone would have had the courage to involuntarily commit me. Perhaps if they did I wouldn’t have suffered with a spinal cord injury, my kids wouldn’t have been so traumatized by months and months of hospitalizations where they were told I might die, I wouldn’t have suffered catastrophic leg wounds requiring a dozen surgeries etc. Moreover, perhaps some of my friends would still be alive who didn’t make it. I think about this more than anything. Did I love some people to death by supporting them when they were on the street? I wrestle with a lot of those hard realities every single day. I feel like some of the guys who went off to war and came back protestors. I have seen and experienced firsthand the horrors of tranq and I have changed my mind on harm reduction. Harm reduction has to have a trajectory that ends with recovery. It must be focused on keeping people alive to get them off the drugs. My conscience has to be clear when I pay my head down at night. I can’t play around and pretend like drugs are cool and fun, they destroy lives and rob people of themselves. I have total compassion for the underlying reasons why people use drugs, I get it. I really do, but I won’t pretend like they are a good coping mechanism anymore. I was really wrong with some of my statements I have made in the past.

The drugs out on the streets today are not like they way they were in the past in so many ways. I am saying that as a medical professional and through what I experienced using them. In the years I was injecting heroin I think I got one infection. When the new combinations hit the streets, infections which had been rare became common. I was septic multiple times. One time a doctor told me that if the IV antibiotic he gave me did not work, I needed to call my family and put my affairs in order because I had a 90% chance of dying. These drug combinations impacted my heart. I ended up with anemia and chronic inflammation. There is no such thing as safe use of these drugs, that is a fallacy.

I support harm reduction that keeps people alive to find recovery. The teleological end point of harm reduction has to be on a trajectory that ends with recovery. I was on the streets on Philadelphia homeless for 3 years in the 2000s. 99% of IV drug users from that era are Hep C positive. I am Hepatitis and HIV negative because I used the syringe service program in Philadelphia. The science backs it up as well as my personal experience. Naloxone is critical today because everything is contaminated with fentanyl. However, in our efforts to confront stigma, we have somehow gotten to a point where we downplay and have stigmatized recovery. Ten years ago when we started coming out of the church basements and openly celebrating recovery it was uncomfortable and tough but seeing other people recovering made me feel like I could do it too. It gave me hope. It seems like there is a countermovement today to normalize drug use and shame recovery. I recently heard someone who runs an overdose hotline (a much needed service) say they aren’t there so people get into recovery, they are only there to keep people safe. It feels like there is an implication that recovery isn’t “cool” anymore, Their reasoning is to reduce stigma for folks who use drugs. We all know stigma kills. However, we run the risk of trying to normalize drug use and I personally cannot get behind that type of messaging. Drugs almost killed me and left me with lifelong medical complications. My addiction severely affected my family. I watched my neighbor teach my son how to throw a football out the window when I was confined to a chair. I’ll never get that back. I was under the illusion that drugs made me a better person, they didn’t. I thought I was a better person, but everyone around me will tell you that is a lie. We can be compassionate and understand that people use drugs to manage severe mental trauma and illness, however we do not have to accept the behavior that comes with drugs use and normalize it. The real issue is this, regardless how someone feels internally while using drugs they are not better people on drugs. Drugs do not make someone a better person. No one who is suffering with addiction wants to be there. We have to stop conflating love/compassion with enabling. I know enabling is a dirty word these days, but I experienced it disguised as caring and evidence-based medicine and it almost killed me.

Harm reduction, which is so very important as a strategy to keep people alive and engage them in processes of recovery, has become traps of low expectations in which even mentioning recovery is seen as a bad thing. In many ways I see this as originating out of the medical model which focuses on chronicity and sees addiction as irreversible. We lost the focus on resiliency and that people with addictions have tremendous, untapped potential. Instead of seeing us as diseased and disordered, we should see the potential for people to get better. Our message to people should be one of hope and potential. That their best days are actually ahead of them in recovery instead of validating them for continuing to use drugs and destroy their lives, the latter was my experience on the streets of Kensington for many years. 

Question Three: We know enough about trauma to know that workers in the medical professions are at a greater risk for SUDs. It is a known occupational hazard. As your substance use increased, did you get support along the way from your field? From the communities you served? Could we do a better job supporting those who serve us in respect to the occupational risks of repeated trauma exposure?

Answer: So, my story is a bit different than many other medical professionals. Most medical folks tend to divert meds from work. I didn’t start that way. I went home with a vial of meds accidentally that I forgot to waste at work. 20 years ago the way we managed narcotics was a lot more relaxed. I was working in the ICU, caring for a critically ill patient who we were dosing every few hours and just forgot to throw away the vial when I went home. I had been suffering with depression at the time and decided to try it. I was fundamentally opposed to stealing meds from work, but realized how effective it was to treat my depression. This led to me seeking out street heroin. Once I was addicted and started experiencing withdrawal I took a leave of absence. At the time there were two other people who knew about my struggle, and they were more concerned with keeping it quiet to help me avoid discipline than getting me help. It is a very common reaction because no one knows what to do with someone who all of a sudden starts using heroin. Especially back then, remember this is pre-opioid crisis where heroin had a much different reputation. I firmly believe if I had been stealing meds from work instead of buying them on the street I would’ve gotten caught and placed in a program and had the usual health professional story of recovery: stole meds from work, got caught, had significant consequences placed over my head, been ushered into a monitoring program etc. In many ways being a man of principle is what led to me having a really rough road because I was so ashamed of developing an addiction to heroin, I independently removed myself from the workplace. I refused to go to work while intoxicated and refused to steal meds from work, I view public trust and patient safety very highly and I was ethically incapable of crossing that line. I should tell you that I’ve never told my story this way before because I was afraid of inadvertently shaming folks who have stolen medications from the hospital. It’s interesting because it certainly would’ve been safer if I had, but I think how my career started wired me differently than a lot of other nurses. I was brought up in the field by mostly military guys. There were a lot of values that were instilled in me. I took an oath and part of that oath contained things like, “I shall abstain from whatever is deleterious and mischievous, and shall not take or knowingly administer any harmful drug,” I took these things very seriously and while I still violated them by engaging off duty, I was fundamentally opposed from stealing drugs and/or using them while responsible for caring for others. I know I sound old fashioned, but it’s just how I’m wired. I still believe holding a professional license to practice medicine is one of the highest honors and privileges we can hold. Therefore, while I completely understand the struggle of addiction, I can never say it’s OK to take meds from work or use while others are counting on you. I did start to experience opioid withdrawal while working which was just as bad, if not, worse, than using on duty. Either way, within 6 months of taking a leave I found myself homeless. I had lost everything. I called the board of nursing and self-reported that I was suffering with heroin addiction. Their response was to immediately suspend my license. That just made everything worse. I wound up spending 3 years on the street homeless until I was incarcerated in 2011. I stole some money from a close friend who then reported it with the hope that jail would sober me up. It did. Again, I am not advocating for jail as a treatment for addiction. During that 6-month jail stay I was brutally sexually assaulted which subsequently resulted in more issues I had to eventually deal with. However, those 6 months did give me time to sober up and find recovery. When I was released, I ended up in a Christian recovery house which sparked a 6 year journey and career in ministry. I wound up going to bible college and then seminary with a focus on counseling. I worked for a few churches in Philadelphia specializing in their homeless and addiction ministries. I wound up meeting my wife at that church, we are still married and three wonderful children. As I said, jail is not the place for people needing to recover, but there is something to be said about taking someone’s liberty and giving them the opportunity to clearly think about their lives and get connected to resources that may actually help them, especially with tranq as I said earlier.

Back to your original question, there wasn’t a system back then to get help. If you struggled with addiction back in 2008 the response was incredibly punitive. We still have a long way to go in terms of how we support medical professionals who struggle with substance use, but we have to stop and take note of how far we’ve come. It’s one of the positives that has come from the opioid crisis. Today we have so many avenues and resources for people to get help. Today, when I go to the ER there are triage questions about substance use. People congratulate you on your recovery today, that did not happen back then. Things today are so much better than they have ever been and it’s important to take note of that while acknowledging we still have a long way to go.

Question Four: Bill I am familiar with your story and know parts of it. Your journey into recovery has not been an easy one. In some of your writings and our conversations, you have spoken about a sense of pervasive apathy from those in our SUD and medical care systems that you encountered. That there was low expectations in respect to your capacity to recover. Can you expand on this?

Answer: My sense is all these professional systems want you to get better, but not too much better because fully recovering means they aren’t needed anymore. In order for me to find recovery I tried 32 failed Buprenorphine inductions and eventually went on methadone, but after a year I decided to taper off and ran into significant push back by my physicians.Methadone was necessary for recovery, but I found it really difficult to function on methadone. I would sit down and fall asleep for at least three hours every day, it made me incredibly drowsy. That was manageable, but I also had a really difficult time intellectually. It felt like I just couldn’t use my brain to the degree that I always have, it limited cognition for me. I am not saying I was impaired, not at all. I noticed the same effect when I was taking high doses of gabapentin for neuropathy after my xylazine leg wound surgery which prompted me to taper off of that med too, Methadone also had significant sexual side effects and being a married man in a monogamous relationship who was trying to navigate marriage repair in early recovery, that matters. This is an issue that is not talked about nearly enough. If you look in the literature there are only about 4 papers discussing erectile dysfunction associated with methadone and none of them are papers from the United States. The third reason I decided to taper off methadone was due to life at the clinic. OTPs can make it really difficult to obtain certain goals. I lost the ability to pursue reinstating my nursing license because I went on buprenorphine. There are very strict rules for being a medical professional and going back into medicine was big goal for me. That was one reason. Daily dosing is another issue. Despite SAMHSA changing guidelines for take homes and recommending 28 doses for stable patients, my clinic still makes you earn take homes through negative drug screens. Every 3 months you earn 1 take home. It would’ve taken over 7 years to earn 1 month of take homes. There are a number of policies like this which made clinic life impossible for me.

What I found is addiction medicine physicians are so focused on evidence-based practice that they forget that not everyone fits into the mold. If a certain modality is effective for 90% of the population, there is still 10% that it isn’t effective for and there isn’t a place for folks like me, who operate a little outside the norm. I had very good reasons for tapering off. Moreover, my life objectively displayed a life of what we would describe as solid, stable recovery. I was abstinent from street drugs, my marriage was better, I was involved in my children’s lives, I started volunteering in multiple areas and started retraining to enter the medical profession as a paramedic. None of this was considered. I was heavily pushed to stay on methadone. Once my doc started to get it that I wasn’t going to do that they started pushing to convince me to go on buprenorphine. Even though I was over 2 years into recovery my doc noted that I was noncompliant with treatment because I tapered off methadone. Here’s what made me realize we have gone too far with seeing medication as equal with recovery. Ten years ago, we would congratulate someone who tapered off methadone and got their lives back. Methadone was incredibly difficult to get off of. It took time and discipline, but it was possible. Not many people get off it. There is a lot of stigma surrounding the medication and a lot of fear that you’ll get stuck on it for the rest of your life. That’s why I was so reluctant to go on it at first, I was scared I’d be on it forever. However, I believe there is a subset of the patient population out there that bupe will never work for when it comes to fentanyl. They need a full agonist opioid medication. The transition onto methadone was seamless for me, it was really easy and I wish I had done it sooner instead of playing around with repeated bupe inductions. Tapering off took a year and a half. I had been on 120mg and tapered down 10mg a week until 60mg, then 5mg/week until 20 and then went down 1mg/week. It took a while, but it was also relatively painless. Once I got under 20mg I felt amazing. No drowsiness, not intellectually fogginess. However, once I tapered off the prescribing doc at the clinic made it a point to celebrate the accomplishment, but my addiction doc considered me a noncompliant patient, and I spent 75% of every visit defending my position to taper off. It was exhausting. I had to constantly tell myself that I was doing the right thing for myself and my recovery, but MOUD is heavily pushed these days. So much so that recovery without medications is now considered a less than and unsafe form of recovery. When I initially made the decision to taper off two physicians and a social worker brought my wife and children in and used scare tactics (explicitly giving statistics of the likelihood of overdose and death off MOUD) in order to use them as strategic pawns to force me to reconsider. Thankfully my wife and I are a good team and respect as well as understand each other. Moreover, she saw the same side effects I had noticed while on methadone as well She understood that recovery is more than just abstinence from opioids, it is about living a fruitful and meaningful life. Physicians are sometimes too data driven and need to be more human.

Addiction medicine as a subspecialty has only been recognized for ten years. Most of the younger addiction docs today were trained and came into practice during the opioid crisis. This matters. Many of them were personally affected by opioids, either themselves or their family members. They trained during a time where we were losing over 100,000 people a year to overdose, they took this issue personally; many of them simultaneously completed MPH programs during medical school to help address the crisis. Moreover, from an epidemiological perspective who do we tend to look for for answers? Physicians. These folks took this responsibility very personally which explains their zeal. However, what many of them haven’t learned yet is that they are the new kids on the block. Recovery and addiction have been managed for over 100 years through various other means. The Washingtonians, Bill Wilson and Dr. Bob, the War on Drugs generated a lot of attention, the whole rehab industry had been around for decades etc. I say this a lot, but the medicine aspect of addiction medicine is only about 5% of recovery. Most people recover without any medication or treatment. It’s tragic that the risk of death has changed things so much, but we have to listen to people when they decide how they want to recover, particularly when it is without medication. I could’ve easily had my life altered if I listened to the doctors this time. I wasn’t myself on methadone and gave good reasons to support my decision to taper off and I do not feel like I was supported. This is a letter of the law vs spirit of the law kind if issue. We are too heavy handed when it comes to medications for opioid use disorder. Not everyone needs to be on lifelong medication. When someone tells you they can’t reach their goals due to a treatment modality their decisions need to be respected. We have shifted how we view things, when ten years ago stigmatizing MOUD to now stigmatizing people who desire abstinence-based recovery. It’s a strange thing to see.

I think a lot of it come from the recovery systems we now have needing to justify their existence, There are a considerable amount of jobs due to the recovery movement today. Opioid settlement funds seem to have really muddied the water here. However, most of them are predicated on keeping people engaged in treatment for as long as possible. If folks recover too well then the programs aren’t needed. I think this is a prevalent undertone. I don’t think anyone is consciously thinking, “I need to keep this person in treatment for a long as possible.” It’s not that sinister. It is more subtle. The docs feel an immense responsibility to solve the crisis and so they are doing it they way docs do, with medication. The other recovery supports are more complex. The advent of peer specialists and “lived experience” becoming such a popular thing has created its own unique issues and this is what is driving, in part, people being restricted in actually living their best lives. In order to be totally free to live my best life I need to be independent and able to make the best choices I can, I couldn’t do that when everyone who was managing my care were constantly doing things that kept me a shell of who I truly am. They continuously tried to get me to believe that I had to accept a diminished version of myself and learn how to live with that, “new normal.” I am very concerned that there are a whole bunch of people out there who will never reach their true potential because they’ll never have the opportunity to try something new. I hope it is clear that I am not anti medication. I needed meds to find recovery. If an individual is where they want to be in life on medication, then good on them. However, when I was going to groups at the methadone clinic there was not one person who enjoyed it. Every single person I have known who is on methadone desperately wants to get off, but is too afraid. A big piece is because we don’t talk about stories where folks have gotten off of it so people think it is impossible, it’s not.

Now when it comes to harm reduction, I also saw some things change over the years that I can’t be on board with. I saw this when I was working at a clinic in Kensington and watched how the focus on distributing life preserving harm reduction tools shifted into a movement for body autonomy for drug users and to affirm drug users rights. People were using drugs right in the clinic and their use was being celebrated. There was no sense of urgency about the risks we let people stay stuck in. I was also impaired and was validated by the harm reduction workers as being ok and I was not ok at all. I lost years of my life as a result. I had to watch my kid learn how to throw a ball from a window as someone else played with him. People who loved me saw differently but the validation and celebration of drug use was part of what kept me using. I am not blaming my relapse on anyone else. I take full responsibility for my choices. However, we tend to emulate the qualities of the 3-5 people we spend the most time with and I was around a bunch of people who celebrated drug use and it wasn’t good for me. The clinic I worked for helped the homeless folks we served sign up and cash the stimulus checks that were issued in 2020. I then watched them take all that money and go outside and give it to the dealers. That kind of money could’ve gotten them housing for 6 months or more. They were incapable of making good decisions for themselves and we helped them stay stuck in their addiction. Moreover, they celebrated it as a good thing for drug user rights. It just didn’t sit right with me. I lost a lot of sleep over the ethics of what we did and ultimately for me I can’t be a part of that type of stuff. As I have said, drugs do not make people better people. They may temporarily make certain situations more bearable for a portion of time, but it comes with consequences.

This is harm in the name of help, and we need to look at it, but that is politically unpopular. When I was advocating for drug use, I would get calls for interviews and to share my thoughts. I was interviewed regularly for national newspapers. I was part of a campaign where my face was on billboards and on the back of buses throughout Philadelphia. I was routinely asked to lecture at medical schools and be on discussion panels at conferences. Now that I am talking about recovery and have come back from the front lines challenging some of what we do none of those groups call me at all. We need to stop celebrating drug use with people living in cardboard boxes on the streets and actually help them. Harm reduction must lead to recovery. I had potential that was overlooked under the assumption of low expectations. I have potential as do those still stuck on our streets. I want the best for them. We all should.

Question Five: A few weeks back we sat down for coffee, and we both saw that there were instances in our lives when we were not in our right minds and capable of making healthy decisions. As an aside, I recently spoke with a medical professional in another city. He had been doing street medicine and woman he had regularly encountered and handed harm reduction tools to came back to him in recovery and was angry with him that he had left her in that state and failed to actually help her. Is some of help we provide people selling them short?

Answer: I think that some of our street medicine and harm reduction strategies are selling people short. I recall a young doctor who worked with me on the street for a few years. I don’t think she ever really saw me. I had lectured at the medical school she graduated from but to her I was just another street addict (at least that is how I felt), even as there is no one on the street that is just anything. We are all people with potential, and our systems of low expectation care fails to see any of it. As I said, the system itself is designed to keep people engaged for their entire lives. It’s a shame because if you talk to any of the folks who are on the ground, doing the actual work, you will quickly begin to understand that their hearts are in the right place. They vehemently care about this population. The issue is they don’t see how they themselves are part of the system that is keeping people down. I don’t tend to view myself as a victim anymore because when you use that framework your recovery is always limited by someone else, again dependency on the system. However, the day I started taking responsibility for my part of my struggle with addiction is the day things began to get remarkably better. It was empowering mentally for me in a liberating way. When I tried to view myself as having an incurable, chronic, relapsing brain disease I felt broken. Destined to relapse over and over which meant I was a liability. That framework also meant I was dependent on others to survive. For me personally I found it debilitating and I know that there are others who feel the same. I am not arguing the evidence that supports the disease model, I know there is a plethora of evidence that can be used to argue that point of view. However, I am also an academic medical professional. I know how to critically analyze research papers. I also know how corrupt our system of medicine can be in terms of how papers get funded, how the data is analyzed, who decides what gets published in what journal etc. Just because something is evidenced based doesn’t mean it is without criticism and the brain disease model is far from settled science in my opinion. It has value and does answer some questions, but it is far from the only way to view and treat addiction. What I am saying is how someone frames their struggle can dictate how they recover. Some people find solace and comfort in understanding their addiction through the lens of the disease model. It gives them an understanding that gives them hope and peace. There are others who don’t. I think we have to focus on our initial assessment tools to be able to properly survey folks to see which personality type they are before we prescribe any specific pathway of recovery for them. I spent 16 years chasing something that never made sense to me and ultimately kept me from reaching my true potential.

Question Six: Do you have any final thoughts / things that are important for readers to learn from your experiences?

Answer: I think we are selling people short and we need to stop doing so. The harm reduction groups want drugs to be safe so they speak in ways that can carry the implied message that they are. These drugs are not safe to use they are deadly and we have to stop pretending they can be made safe. The reasons people use drugs are valid. These folks are legitimately suffering and deserve relief, however the garbage on the street is not compassion. The people making and selling these drugs are not good people. They will destroy your life for profit. We have to be honest about this. The whole thing has led to a sort of anti-recovery movement. Abstinence based recovery is looked down on and actively stigmatized. We have stigmatized recovery and normalized addiction.  I recently heard some addiction medicine physicians talking about an episode of The Pitt where there was someone using xylazine and had severe wounds, smaller versions of the ones I had, and the treating doctor on the show asked the person to consider stopping using and they saw that as horrible and something that should not be done. This blew me away and is exactly the wrong way to go. Every single hour someone stays out on the street using tranq we are dramatically extending the amount of time it will take them to recover, if they ever do. We must do everything we can to get in between the drugs and the person so they can live their best lives. Unfortunately, the drugs on the street are so dangerous they have caught up with the propaganda we were told in the 80s. One time can kill you and every use carries the risk of lifelong disability. This is nothing to play around with.

If you are a medical professional who cares for people who use drugs start having the difficult conversations. I helped train physicians for over a decade. We used to teach physicians that they had the ultimate responsibility of being courageous. They were the ones who bared the responsibility of having difficult, blunt, but lifesaving conversations with people. Please get back to being those types of professionals. What I experienced between 2020-2025 was completely foreign to me as a medical professional. Physicians were scared to tell me the truth, and their niceness was almost fatal for me; makes me wonder how many folks I know weren’t so fortunate. Lives are ending and people are becoming disabled while we wait around for them to be ready. Unfortunately, we don’t have the luxury of coddling people until they’re ready for help. I hate that we’re here, but it’s the truth. We need to actually help people get into recovery.We need to make recovery the goal again and celebrate it loudly.

Beyond all that, there are a lot of things I have learned about recovery from these drug combinations that I would want to share with professionals. Just because I have a different viewpoint than you about drugs, addiction, and recovery doesn’t mean we can’t collaborate. When I got sober things changed with the way my xylazine wounds healed. There were dozens of new issues that no one is talking about. Please pick my brain and let me help you with this subset of the population. I can help tremendously. If you truly do care for these folks do the difficult thing let me help. We can disagree on some things but still work together. Just because I feel strongly about telling people to stop using doesn’t mean I can’t help find solutions to better wound management. Sure, we’ll disagree, we’ll argue; but we’re adults and scientists. Disagreement is how diseases get cured. Get a little uncomfortable and reach out. Right now, there aren’t any case reports or articles about patients who have faced amputation and recovered. Limb salvage is possible for people like me. One way we could really help is to start writing articles about folks who have recovered. This would generate hope in other clinicians. I faced considerable apathy with most of the docs I met who I saw for wound care. I believe we can change that and the only way to do it is to show the world that people can avoid amputation. Recovery from xylazine is resource intensive and considerable, this is why getting folks to stop using is so critical. No surgeon will touch one of these wounds without significant recovery and a solid infrastructure and support network. This isn’t due to stigma; it’s due to resources and the reality of what these wounds need to heal. I care deeply about this population. Please invite me to help find solutions for them. Few people have sustained recovery from xylazine and with my medical background there are things I wish I could share. It is very odd that more people wanted to hear me talk about using these drugs than what I have learned since recovering from them. It should be the other way around.

We should want people to get better. We should want the very best for people. We should have high expectations of recovery, and my experience was the exact opposite. Let’s take a good look at what we are doing and do better. 

Sources

Fleming, R., Fogler, S., Stauffer, W., & Sargent, R. H. (2023, February). Opportunities for change: An analysis of drug use and recovery stigma in the U.S. healthcare system. Pennsylvania Recovery Organizations Alliance. https://pro-a.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/Opportunities-for-Change-An-analysis-of-drug-use-and-recovery-stigma-in-the-U.S.-healthcare-system-3.pdf

Kinkle, W. (n.d.). William Kinkle [ResearchGate profile]. ResearchGate. Retrieved October 18, 2026, from https://www.researchgate.net/profile/William-Kinkle

Halsall L, Irizar P, Burton S, Waring S, Giles S, Goodwin L and Jones A (2023) Hazardous, harmful, and dependent alcohol use in healthcare professionals: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Front. Public Health 11:1304468. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2023.1304468 https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38089041/

Mercer, L., Cookson, Alex, Simpson-Adkins, G., & van Vuuren, J. (2023). Prevalence of adverse childhood experiences and associations with personal and professional factors in health and social care workers: A systematic review. Psychological Trauma: Theory, Research, Practice, and Policy, 15(Suppl 1), S231–S245. https://doi.org/10.1037/tra0001506

Rich A, Viney R, Silkens M, Griffin A, Medisauskaite A. The experiences of students with mental health difficulties at medical school: a qualitative interview study. Med Educ Online. 2024 Dec 31;29(1):2366557. doi: 10.1080/10872981.2024.2366557. Epub 2024 Jun 13. PMID: 38870397; PMCID: PMC11177711. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11177711/

Shah J, Smith C, Mostert C, Khakali L, Merali Z, Ali SK. Substance use among healthcare professionals: A cross-sectional study in Kenya. PLOS Glob Public Health. 2025 Mar 24;5(3):e0003863. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0003863. PMID: 40127086; PMCID: PMC11932460. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40127086/

Splete, H. (2005, May 1). Methadone’s impact on libido hurts compliance. Clinical Psychiatry News. https://www.mdedge.com/clinicalpsychiatrynews/article/22263/addiction-medicine/methadones-impact-libido-hurts-compliance

Stauffer, W. (2026, October 17). Pathways of long-term recovery and the rhetoric of “zombie drugs.” Recovery Review. https://recoveryreview.blog/2026/10/17/pathways-of-long-term-recovery-and-the-rhetoric-of-zombie-drugs/

Volkow ND, Koob GF, McLellan AT. Neurobiologic Advances from the Brain Disease Model of Addiction. N Engl J Med. 2016 Jan 28;374(4):363-71. doi: 10.1056/NEJMra1511480. PMID: 26816013; PMCID: PMC6135257. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6135257/

Why health-care professionals often do not ask for help: Understanding the stigma associated with substance use disorders. (2023). Nursing Clinics of North America, 58(2), 153–164. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cnur.2023.02.008

Leave a Reply