Not a harmless herb with a dangerous cousin — one product line, one pathway

Tom Watkins (former state superintendent of Michigan’s schools, former state mental health director, and former president and CEO of Detroit Wayne Integrated Health Network (DWIHN), the largest community mental health agency in Michigan) recently wrote a commentary for Michigan Advance on pending legislation to ban kratom in Michigan.

Eight months have passed since the Michigan House of Representatives voted to ban kratom. As the Legislature enters its final lame duck stretch of 2026, an addictive, unregulated substance remains as easy for a teenager to buy as a Snickers bar….

Not a harmless herb with a dangerous cousin — one product line, one pathway

The kratom industry wants Michigan to believe there are two separate products: a gentle, centuries-old herbal leaf and a dangerous lab-made outlier. Ban the bad one, they say, and leave the leaf alone.

That is a distinction designed to protect a business model, not our kids.

Watkins, T. (2026, November 17). Lame duck ultimatum: Get kratom off Michigan’s store shelves. Michigan Advance.

Communities are implementing bans in the absence of state and federal action

Watkins makes the argument that for a full ban, rather than a partial ban that distinguishes between plant-based products and synthetics, noting that “Banning only 7-OH would invite a game of chemical whack-a-mole: outlaw one derivative and manufacturers will reformulate the next one, while the leaf products that start people down this road stay on the counter next to the candy.”

He argues that the state needs to take action because the federal government appears to be captured by industry, leaving the matter to states and municipalities.

Some other important elements from the legislation include the exemption for anything FDA-approved — the proper pathway for people who might benefit from kratom-based products for medical use.

Also, it makes it a misdemeanor (not a felony) to grow, synthesize, sell, offer to sell, give, import, or distribute kratom or a synthetic variant.

There are people who insist that passing legislation like this diverts our energy, resources, and attention from larger drug problems. I have a difficult time understanding that argument. The state banned K2 in 2012. I don’t think we’ve suffered from its absence or diverted resources. It’s very easy to be suspicious about the motives of these voices, given the industry’s non-transparent use of experts, influencers, and advocates to sow doubt about the harms associated with kratom and support their policy agenda.

Leave a Reply